Professional Negligence.When Paid Advice Costs You Money
For clients of surveyors, accountants, financial advisers, solicitors and other professionals in England and Wales. Smaller claims can sometimes go through the small claims track, but they have their own protocol, longer timescales and a higher bar of proof.
- Small claims up to £10,000
- England & Wales
- No solicitor needed
Most professionals trade through a firm.
The sue a company page explains how to name a limited company or LLP correctly and find the address to serve the claim on.
Sue a companyClaiming against a professional for bad work
Professional negligence is harder to prove than an unpaid bill. You have to show not just that something went wrong, but that no reasonably competent professional would have done it, and that it caused a loss you can put a figure on.
The claims that actually come up
- Surveyors. A survey that missed a defect a competent surveyor would have spotted, such as an obvious roof or damp problem.
- Accountants and tax advisers. Late filing leading to penalties, or errors that caused you to pay more tax or interest than you should.
- Financial advisers. Unsuitable advice or products. These usually go to the Financial Ombudsman Service first.
- Solicitors and conveyancers. Missed deadlines or errors in a transaction. Complaints about service go to the Legal Ombudsman.
- Fee disputes. A professional suing you for unpaid fees, where you say the work was negligent.
What you have to prove
- A duty. Usually your contract with them, and a duty of care in negligence alongside it.
- A breach. The work fell below the standard of a reasonably competent member of that profession. Hindsight is not enough, and a judgement call that other competent professionals would have made is not negligent.
- Causation and loss. The breach caused a financial loss. For a negligent survey, the loss is often measured as the difference between what you paid and what the property was actually worth, rather than the cost of repairs.
- Expert evidence. Breach is normally proved with an independent expert from the same profession. In the small claims track, expert evidence needs the court’s permission and the expert fees you can recover from the other side are capped at a modest amount.
Complaints and ombudsman routes come first
Start with the firm’s complaints procedure. Regulated professionals must have one.
- Financial advice. The Financial Ombudsman Service is free for consumers and can award compensation. You normally have to complain to the firm first and give it time to respond.
- Solicitors and other lawyers. The Legal Ombudsman deals with poor service and can order compensation or fee reductions, once you have complained to the firm and allowed it eight weeks.
- Surveyors and accountants. Their professional bodies handle conduct complaints and some run redress schemes, but a professional body may not award compensation. If you want your loss paid, a claim is often the route.
Most professionals carry professional indemnity insurance, and a properly made claim is usually passed to the insurer. That can make settlement more realistic than in other small disputes.
The Professional Negligence Pre-Action Protocol
Claims against most professionals have their own Pre-Action Protocol for Professional Negligence. It expects a detailed Letter of Claim setting out what happened, what you say went wrong, why, and what loss it caused. The professional then has a set period to acknowledge it and up to three months to investigate and send a Letter of Response. It also encourages settlement and alternative dispute resolution. Claims against architects, engineers and similar construction professionals normally follow the construction and engineering protocol instead.
If you are the professional chasing an unpaid fee from an individual client, the Pre-Action Protocol for Debt Claims applies to your claim, with 30 days to reply. Expect any negligence complaint to come back as a counterclaim.
Is it a small claim at all?
Claims of £10,000 or less are normally allocated to the small claims track, where each side usually bears its own legal costs. Above that, claims normally go to the fast track or higher, where the loser usually pays a share of the winner’s legal costs, in the fast track at fixed amounts. You can choose to limit your claim to £10,000, but you then give up the rest for good.
A judge can allocate a complex professional negligence claim to a higher track even if it is worth less than £10,000. If your claim depends on disputed expert evidence, budget for that.
The route, step by step
Complain to the firm.
In writing, with what went wrong and what you want. Keep the response.
Use the ombudsman if there is one.
For financial advice and legal services this is usually free and faster than court.
Get an expert view.
Before issuing, a short opinion from an independent professional on whether the work fell below the standard and what loss it caused.
Follow the protocol.
Send the Letter of Claim and give the professional the time the protocol allows to respond.
Issue the claim online.
If the deadline in your letter passes without payment, you can issue the claim yourself through Money Claim Online or the GOV.UK "Make a money claim" service. You state a fixed sum, a short description of the claim and any interest, and pay the issue fee. The defendant needs an address for service in England or Wales.
Wait for the response.
Once the claim is served, the defendant normally has 14 days to pay, admit, or file a defence, or 28 days in total if they file an acknowledgment of service first. If they do nothing, you can ask the court for judgment in default.
Free mediation if it is defended.
Many defended small money claims are referred to a free one-hour telephone session with the HMCTS Small Claims Mediation Service before a hearing is listed. See our guide to mandatory mediation.
Directions and the small claims track.
If it does not settle, both sides complete a directions questionnaire and the court allocates the case. Claims up to £10,000 normally go to the small claims track, where the procedure is simpler and each side usually pays its own legal costs. The court then sets dates for exchanging documents and witness statements, and you pay the hearing fee.
The hearing.
Small claims hearings are informal and often short. A district judge reads the papers, asks both sides questions and gives a decision, usually the same day. Our guide to what to expect at the hearing covers the day itself.
Judgment and enforcement.
If you win and they still do not pay, the court has enforcement options such as a warrant of control or an attachment of earnings order. Each has its own fee.
Time limits
Under the Limitation Act 1980 the basic period is 6 years, from the breach for a contract claim or from when you suffered damage for a negligence claim. Where you could not have known about the damage until later, negligence claims may have an extra period of three years from when you knew, or should have known, enough to bring the claim, subject to an overall limit of 15 years from the negligent act. The ombudsman schemes have their own time limits. These rules are technical, so if you are close to any deadline, take advice.
Where CourtPilot fits
CourtPilot is software for people bringing or defending their own small claim. It is not a law firm, it does not give legal advice and nobody here reviews your case as a lawyer. You decide what to send and you sign it in your own name.
The free case check asks a few questions about your professional negligence dispute and tells you whether it looks like a small claim, which pre-action rules apply and when the time limit runs out. For a straightforward claim up to about £1,500 it usually suggests the £29 Claim Pack (letter before claim, particulars of claim and the N1, with the interest and fee worked out). Above that it usually suggests the £49 small claims toolkit, which carries the case through mediation, the hearing bundle and enforcement. £1,500 is the point where we suggest one or the other, not a limit: you can choose either. If you are the one being sued, the £49 defence toolkit covers one defended claim. All are one-off payments with a 14-day refund policy.
Court fees for a money claim
Issue and hearing fees depend on the total you claim, including interest. Expert fees are on top and are only partly recoverable in the small claims track.
The issue fee runs from £35 for a claim up to £300 to £455 for a claim of £10,000. If the case goes to a hearing there is a second fee, from £27 to £346 on the small claims track. See the full fee table by claim amount or use the court fee calculator for your exact figure.
Fees from the HMCTS fee list (EX50), last checked against gov.uk on 2026-10-19. Fees change, so check gov.uk before you pay. If you are on a low income you may qualify for Help with Fees (form EX160). Court fees you pay are normally added to the claim and can be ordered against the other side if you win.
Worked example: a survey that missed a roof defect
A buyer pays £240,000 for a house after a survey reports the roof in reasonable condition. Months later a roofer finds slipped and broken tiles and a sagging section clearly visible from the ground. An independent surveyor gives the opinion that a competent survey would have flagged it, and values the house with the defect at £233,000 at the date of purchase.
The buyer complains to the surveying firm, which passes the matter to its insurer. With no offer, the buyer sends a Letter of Claim under the Professional Negligence Pre-Action Protocol and waits for the response period to run before issuing.
| Price paid | £240,000 |
| Value with the defect | £233,000 |
| Loss claimed (difference in value) | £7,000 |
| Issue fee (£5,000.01 – £10,000) | £455 |
| Hearing fee if defended | £346 |
This is an invented scenario to show how the figures and steps fit together. It is not a CourtPilot customer and says nothing about how any real case will turn out. Fees from the HMCTS fee list (EX50). Whether a claim like this stays in the small claims track is for the judge.
CourtPilot is not a law firm and this page is general information about the law in England and Wales, not legal advice. If your situation is complicated or the sum is large, consider speaking to a solicitor or Citizens Advice.
Guides for professional negligence claims
Background reading before you start.
- Negligent advice
- Property
- Money and tax
- Insurance
When court makes sense. And what to have ready.
Many disputes settle after a complaint or a firm letter. These are the signs a small claim is worth considering.
- You have complained to the firm and used any ombudsman route that applies
- An independent professional supports your view that the work fell below standard
- You can put a figure on the loss the mistake caused, ideally £10,000 or less
- You are inside the time limit, with time to follow the protocol
- Complaint made to the firm
- Ombudsman route checked
- Independent expert view obtained
- Protocol Letter of Claim sent
From the paperwork you have to documents you can send.
Upload your dispute
Contracts, invoices, order confirmations, messages and photos. CourtPilot pulls out the dates, amounts and who said what.
Draft the documents
The letter before claim under the right pre-action rules, the particulars of claim and the claim form, with interest and the court fee worked out.
Keep the case moving
Deadline tracking after you issue, and for cases that go further, the hearing bundle and witness statement.
- Free check of time limits
- Structured Letter of Claim
- Particulars of claim and N1
- Deadline tracking after issue
Professional Negligence: common questions
Can I sue my surveyor for missing a defect?
Possibly, if a reasonably competent surveyor doing the same type of survey would have spotted it, and you lost money as a result. The loss is often measured as the difference between what you paid and what the property was really worth at the time, which usually needs an independent valuation.
Do I need an expert report?
Almost always. Whether a professional fell below the standard of their profession is normally proved with evidence from an independent expert in the same field. In the small claims track you need the court’s permission to rely on it, and the expert fees you can recover are capped.
What is the Professional Negligence Pre-Action Protocol?
A set of steps the courts expect before you issue a claim against most professionals. You send a detailed Letter of Claim and the professional has a period to acknowledge it and up to three months to investigate and respond. Skipping it can count against you.
How long do I have to bring a claim?
Generally six years from the breach or from when you suffered damage. For negligence where you only found out later, there may be an extra three years from when you knew enough to claim, with an overall limit of 15 years. These rules are technical, so take advice if you are near a deadline.
My claim is worth more than £10,000. What happens?
It will normally be allocated to the fast track or a higher track, where the losing side usually pays some of the winner’s legal costs. You can limit your claim to £10,000 to stay in the small claims track, but you then cannot recover the rest later.
Can CourtPilot tell me whether the professional was negligent?
No. CourtPilot is not a law firm and does not give legal advice. Professional negligence claims often need specialist advice, and many solicitors offer an initial assessment. CourtPilot can help you organise the facts and prepare your own documents.
Different line of work?
The same court route, with the rules and disputes each sector actually sees.
- England & Wales
Written for the County Court.
Scotland and Northern Ireland have different rules and courts.
- Civil Procedure Rules
Drafted to the rules.
Letters and claim documents follow the Civil Procedure Rules and the relevant pre-action rules.
- One-off prices
No subscription.
The free case check costs nothing. Claim Pack £29 for one claim, or the small claims toolkit at £49. 14-day refund policy.
CourtPilot provides tools and guidance to help you prepare your own small claims case. We are not a law firm, nobody at CourtPilot reviews your case as a lawyer, and we cannot give legal advice. For complex matters, or if you are unsure of your rights, consult a qualified solicitor or Citizens Advice.
Find out if your claim stacks up
The free case check looks at the time limit, the likely track and the steps that come before court.
